Long Island Commercial Real Estate Market Update – 2025 Year End Report
Long Island's commercial real estate market closed 2025 with a historic level of transaction activity across Nassau and Suffolk counties — a dramatic acceleration from the prior year driven largely by the second half of 2025, when stabilizing interest rates unlocked capital that had been sitting idle. End-user buyers in the $5 million to $25 million range were among the most active participants, defining the year as one of purposeful, owner-driven acquisition. This wasn't speculative buying — it was strategic, long-term positioning by buyers who recognized that well-located product at today's pricing represents a generational opportunity.
Sector Performance
Long Island's office sector closed 2025 on its strongest footing in years. Vacancy improved meaningfully from its recent peak, dipping into the low-to-mid 13% range by year-end — the most significant improvement the market has seen since before the pandemic-era disruptions. Leasing volume held steady throughout the year, with tenant renewals increasing and demand for updated, well-located space outpacing older product. A flight to quality defined the year's narrative: tenants proved willing to pay record asking rents for the right space, while older Class B and C inventory found buyers and tenants who recognized the value-add opportunity. For owners of well-positioned office assets, 2025 demonstrated that the Long Island office market has turned a corner.
Industrial remained Long Island's most consistent performer and most competitive investment category throughout 2025. Vacancy held in the low single digits by year-end, continuing to rank among the tightest industrial markets in the entire Northeast region. Leasing activity surged at multiple points during the year, driven by sustained demand from logistics, distribution, and last-mile delivery users concentrated primarily in central Nassau and western Suffolk. Asking rents remained at historically elevated levels compared to prior cycles, and investment sales continued to trade at premium pricing. While some softening in large-block Class A activity emerged in the fourth quarter, the broader industrial story for 2025 was one of durability — a market supported by structural supply constraints and tenants who simply need to be on Long Island.
Retail on Long Island outperformed virtually every national benchmark in 2025 and continues to stand as one of the most compelling investment stories in the suburban New York market. Vacancy held in the low single digits across Nassau and Suffolk — among the tightest of any property type — a direct result of years of limited new construction and consistently strong consumer demand. Mid-sized retail spaces in Nassau County saw some of the sharpest rent growth of any submarket, while essential service tenants, medical users, food and beverage operators, and experiential concepts continued to absorb available space quickly. For investors, Long Island retail continued to trade at competitive cap rates reflecting the market's confidence in the asset class's ability to generate durable, predictable cash flow regardless of broader economic conditions.
Multifamily closed 2025 as one of the Island's most in-demand investment categories, and the fundamentals supporting that demand show no signs of weakening. Occupancy rates across stabilized apartment communities remained near full, and while rent growth moderated from the aggressive pace of 2022 and 2023, the underlying demand story is unchanged. Long Island's housing supply remains structurally constrained — Nassau County's available inventory represents a fraction of what a balanced market would require — keeping rental demand elevated and vacancy near historic lows. Cap rates for stabilized multifamily assets remain the tightest of any sector, a direct reflection of the premium investors place on the asset class's stability and long-term cash flow profile. Transit-oriented multifamily development continued to advance across Nassau County's established downtowns, with several significant projects receiving municipal approvals and moving toward construction — a pipeline that will shape the multifamily landscape well into the next cycle.
Major Deals of 2025
The single largest transaction on Long Island in 2025 was the acquisition of five Bristal Assisted Living facilities for approximately $603 million, acquired by Ventas from B2K Development and Harrison Street Asset Management. The deal was a landmark moment for the region, putting Long Island on the national map for institutional healthcare investment and signaling the growing appetite among large-scale capital allocators for specialty-use assets in the suburban New York market.
A fully occupied 139,470 SF warehouse at 50 Cabot Court in Hauppauge sold for $27 million in November 2025, reflecting the sustained premium pricing that well-located Long Island industrial assets continue to command. The property, situated near the Long Island Expressway in one of Suffolk County's most active logistics corridors, traded at approximately $194 per square foot.
A fully occupied 76,000 SF industrial building at 1 Brooklyn Road in Hempstead was acquired by J.P. Morgan Real Estate Income Trust in July 2025 at a 5.7% cap rate, pricing the asset at approximately $18.6 million. The involvement of a major institutional buyer at that cap rate level was a strong validation of Long Island industrial as a core, investment-grade asset class worthy of national capital.
RXR's sale of the 252,000 SF Nassau West Corp 2 office building at 50 Charles Lindbergh Boulevard in Uniondale closed in October 2025 for $15.5 million, with the buyer acquiring a 74% leased, six-story asset at roughly $61 per square foot. The transaction reflected the selective but active appetite among private investors for large-format office product at pricing that leaves room for value creation through lease-up and repositioning.
Market Outlook
While many firms are still debating market conditions, North Village Realty is out in front — executing the most meaningful and complex transactions across the corridor. These results are not forecasts or marketing claims; they are documented outcomes achieved for property owners just like you. We are not simply listing properties. We are shaping the transactions that influence pricing and guide investor expectations. That level of impact is earned only through consistent performance and a deep understanding of this market. When the time comes to transition from holding a valuable asset to maximizing its return, you should align with a brokerage whose current track record demonstrates clear market command.
2025 proved that Long Island commercial real estate does not wait for perfect conditions — it moves when the opportunity is clear. The record transaction volume of the year was built on conviction, not speculation: end users securing long-term occupancy, family offices acquiring generational assets, and private investors deploying capital into sectors with proven, durable fundamentals.
Heading into 2026, the themes remain consistent. Industrial and retail will continue to attract the most competitive pricing and the deepest buyer pools. Office will reward owners who invest in quality and position their assets correctly within a market that is actively recovering. Multifamily will remain a top target for private capital as Long Island's housing supply constraints show no signs of easing and transit-oriented development reshapes key submarkets.
For owners, investors, and tenants navigating this market, the difference between a good outcome and a great one comes down to local knowledge, real-time transaction data, and a broker who understands how capital actually moves on Long Island.
Within North Village Realty, this is exactly what we provide.
At North Village Realty, we specialize in seller representation and provide tailored strategies to maximize your property’s value. If you are considering selling or want to understand your asset’s place in today’s market, contact us today for a complimentary Broker Opinion of Value (BOV).
Article by Tom Bigansky, Managing Broker – North Village Realty
Long Island Business News: Emerging Leaders
New York Real Estate Journal: One’s to Watch Spotlight